Swancoat wrote:I think you could solve that issue with a different weather station. I have a Davis that provides both of those, and I only have one instance of WeatherSnoop running.

[/quote]

The Davis would be great for outdoors and that's what I'm considering but for inside temp/humidity they seem a little overkill for me considering their size and cost for sensors.

"Do you stock (or are you thinking about stocking) any of the 433MHz security modules that the plugin supposidly supports?"

John,
Maybe . . . can you point me toward some specific examples?

jay (support) wrote:
The RFX plugin, in terms of receiving data, seems rock solid already. So, for those who don't care about history and weather graphs may want to consider going with the RFXtrx433/RFXrec433 transceiver and the OS sensors. Since the RFX device supports all versions of the OS sensor protocols, you can use more sensors than the OS base stations can (which are generally limited to one specific protocol version).

Note also that the last time I had conversations with the WeatherSnoop guys they were going to drop support for the Oregon Scientific weather stations in the next major release so if you've already invested in OS systems this is an alternative.

Very good to know. As I already have OS sensors for bedrooms, refrigerator..etc. Here I was waiting for WeatherSnoop to allow for two instances to be running so as to add outside weather. I would much rather split that apart as I don't really need to track indoor temp/humidity. When I emailed WeatherSnoop I didn't get any sense that they'd be dropping OS sensor support so thanks for passing that along as that will certainly help me in deciding which path to choose. I find it difficult to look for Indigo add-ons. It would be nice to view add-ons/plug-ins by feature provided, necessary hardware...etc.

For those using the RFX Plugin and OS sensors have you found the range to be about the same or improved?

AlaskaDave wrote:I find it difficult to look for Indigo add-ons. It would be nice to view add-ons/plug-ins by feature provided, necessary hardware...etc.

The Plugin Wish List and the File Library are about as close as it comes at the moment. Eventually we'll have a plugin store that will be the central place to find plugins.

AlaskaDave wrote:For those using the RFX Plugin and OS sensors have you found the range to be about the same or improved?

I think the range is a little better - I had a hard time placing my OS sensors (specifically the wind and range sensors) so that my WMR100 could find them. As I stated above the sensors work inside in opposite ends of the house so the range is great.

norm wrote:"Do you stock (or are you thinking about stocking) any of the 433MHz security modules that the plugin supposidly supports?"

John,
Maybe . . . can you point me toward some specific examples?

I realize that this is getting away from weather, and it looks almost like it should be a different thread, and you probably arent the one to ask anyway... But my problem is that I, as a simple end user, am finding it tough to find out what specific sensors would work with the plugin... I haven't added door open detection simply because while the insteon triggerlincs could add that functionality fairly cheaply, they are kind of obvious; I know DSC makes a nice line of 433 MHz magnetic contact sensors that can be imbedded in the door or window frame for about the same price, but can't find any way to cross reference as to whether they would be compatible with the plugin. I know it's compatible with more than the listed sensors, because it did pick up and recognize my Radio Shack 63-1088 temperature sensor in the freezer when I opened it (going to have to rethink using Indigo for that, though; the metal in the freezer apparently keeps the signal from having enough range to reach across the house to the RFX unless the freezer is open, and when I moved the display that we have hung on the wall over the freezer more than about 15 feet away, it won't pick it up either).

That's a question for the RFXCOM guys - they monitor the forums here - for sure the one for the plugin so you should post these types of questions there. I know that Norm is definitely interested in carrying the sensors that people find useful. I also know that adding various 433MHz sensors to the RFXrec firmware isn't a trivial exercise so they have to make sure there's demand just like we do when we're presented with hardware support requests.

The good news is that the RFXCOM firmware is field upgradeable - so they can add new stuff over time. The plugin may or may not need a revision when new hardware is added I believe, but I think the plan is to try to keep them in sync as much as possible. Doing the firmware upgrade at the moment requires running the Windows configuration utility (which can be run somewhat successfully under Mono on the Mac) but we're really hoping that the firmware upgrade process will be added to the plugin so that you don't have to download all that other stuff.